Today, Steve Jobs released an interesting essay justifying Apple’s shut-out of flash in the iPad and iPhone market. Apparently, when you make your first jog toward the light at the end of the tunnel, you’re imbued with a natural inclination to blog more. Maybe I need one of my organs to fail? Anyways, my summary of the high points:
- Open – Flash isn’t an open system, it’s closed source and Flash controlled.
- Features – All those flash sites you claim are so important? Yeah, we’ve got apps for those…so shut it.
- Security – Adobe has more bugs than a camel’s armpit, and twice as many security flaws.
- Power Consumption – Because you don’t use hardware acceleration it winds up sucking more processor speed, and therefore power.
- Touch – Have you ever used an iPhone? Yeah, we like touch.
- Flash Apps – Yeah, we’re not going to let you get that foothold. You know how we do quality control. [BAN]
It’s largely concrete and controlled, but my favorite quote is the last paragraph where he unleashes the liver-fed lion:
New open standards created in the mobile era, such as HTML5, will win on mobile devices (and PCs too). Perhaps Adobe should focus more on creating great HTML5 tools for the future, and less on criticizing Apple for leaving the past behind.
I largely agree with everything that Jobs is saying here, with one giant caveat: he shouldn’t have said it. Thousands of other people can say things like this and have it actually mean it, hell….even Ballmer would have gotten some respect from me for this kind of publication. But it wasn’t Ballmer, it wasn’t Zuckerberg, it wasn’t Brin, and it wasn’t even Bezos…it was Jobs.
Apple[Jobs] has created one of, if not the, most closed environments in recent history, barring the PRC. Every developer who wants to play in their app space needs to obey the censors and keep their noses clean, in addition to paying annual fees to enter the market. They continue to be criticized over, over, and over again for their blaze approach to censorship; Jobs even went so far as to tarnish the character of those who dare buy from the enemy. To say these things may seem like a logical attempt to regain trust from developers that “Steve’s really got our backs”, but it doesn’t take a psychology degree to see what his intentions are.
Jobs does not have the user or developers in mind. He’s pushed his teams to exclude flash from the iPlatform because he doesn’t want to lose control of the AppStore reigns. In a nearly-open system one can make the case that singular exclusions of technological compatibility are in the best interest of the consumer. Even Hu Jintao doesn’t whitelist Internet sites for his people. This essay has done nothing but push me closer toward a Verizon store and my first Android phone. I might even buy one of those wacky, now-imaginary Couriers.
Amazing, Steve, just amazing.